Chapter 2: Dalhart

Carving broad lines into the dirt, he circled the tractor at the edge of the field his father farmed as a hired hand, straightened it out, and started anew. Plowing one endless furrow after another, Joel stole a longing glance at the cars speeding past on the adjacent road, each headed anywhere but here. Family duty held him firmly in the driver’s seat of the tractor’s cabin, though he would gladly relinquish it for a ride in the backseat of even the slowest vehicle escaping this dry and dusty patch of land outside of Dalhart. While he would later appreciate the work ethic instilled in him by his father, who expected him and his brothers to do their part by participating in the family trade as long as they remained under his roof, he derived no pleasure in farming and anticipated after graduation a life outside of such a town that offered few, if any, other means of making a living, even to this day.

Granted, there was nothing to discredit the modest, deliberately-paced community of Dalhart, so named for its establishment between Dallam and Hartley counties in the Texas Panhandle. Then again, there was nothing much to its credit either, in Joel’s opinion. Living in a small agrarian town suited men like his father, who had spent his entire life there, was devoted to his trade, and knew as much about the world outside of it as he wanted to and nothing more. In a way, Dalhart was a refuge from the busy, chaotic world beyond beyond its borders. Even my grandfather’s television, a veritable window in one’s living room opened to the wider world, was, as I recall in his later years, rarely tuned to anything other than golf or the weather; there was little else that captured or required his attention, and this by choice. I once asked him if he had ever considered living anywhere else, myself having recently arrived for a visit from the sprawling, noisy metropolis of Houston. “What?!” he exclaimed. “You’d have to be crazy to want to leave this place!”

My father shared no such sentiment, a fact that did not evade the attention of his own father. It isn’t a stretch to say that the numerous years David Johnson had spent working the land as a matter of necessity had become stitched inseparably into his very identity. To have a son who did not find equal meaning in this respectable form of labor was to suffer a personal affront. He was not an emotionally demonstrative man, however, though his departure from his childhood home as a teenager was contentious, to say the least. He made a rebellious escape of his own from a father with whom he didn’t see eye to eye and never once looked back in regret. Exiting the dust-bowl era, he found a way to make life work for him in spite of an unfinished formal education, eloping with his teenage bride, Zola Faye McBrayer, and focusing his life’s labor on tending the land. Five kids were to follow, Joel the fourth in line, preceded by Peggy, Nancy, and Steve, and trailed by Don.

Zola Faye’s fourth was an unplanned pregnancy. To make matters worse, conception was discovered following a procedure his mother had undergone known obstetrically as a “D and C,” which involves clearing tissue from the uterine lining. No viable pregnancy is biologically equipped to withstand such a procedure under the best of circumstances. Upon learning of the mistake, the doctor counseled abortion, convinced the fetus either would not survive or would be born unhealthy or severely disabled. Zola Faye refused. Defying the odds, the baby would be born to term, alive and healthy. She would give him the prophetic Biblical name “Joel,” meaning declaratively “Yahweh (the Lord) is God.” The improbable birth would be documented in medical literature. I would first hear this story many years later in a sermon delivered by my father, who shared of his mother’s conviction that it presaged a life determined for a special purpose or moment.

Whatever that purpose might be, this story would lend Joel a profound sense of God having miraculously intervened in his life long before he possessed a formed mind to perceive it. The words of Psalm 139 might as well had been penned by him, who, incidentally, was given the middle name “David” by his mother and father.

“Your eyes saw my unformed body; all the days were written in your book before one of them came to be.”

Central to this sense of meaning and purpose was the church, and for the Johnson household, attendance was routine and expected for all in the family. His father, David, arrived early every Sunday to open the doors of the First Baptist Church of Dalhart, his deaconly duties extending only insofar as gatekeeper and collector, namely offertory contributions and attendance numbers in Sunday School classes. Aside from this, he characteristically could be relied upon to shutter his eyes during the service not in meditation or prayer but in slumber. Yes, the pastoral message was important; he diligently brought his family each week, after all. It seems, however, he was simply a man who was at his best and most alert when moving, and a sermon afforded little opportunity for that. Zola Faye, by contrast, kept conscious and active attention, teaching the young married’s class, singing in the choir, and occasionally serving as pianist and, for several years, church secretary. As for Joel and his brothers and sisters, they were present and accounted for given the doors were open — Girls in Action, Royal Ambassadors, childrens and youth choir, Sunday evening church training, vacation Bible school, etc. Religious or not, one’s best social opportunities in a small town at that time were often provided by an engaged church, and the Johnsons’ extracurricular activities would imply it was practically a second home for them.

Growing up, Joel’s interests inclined toward literature. His oldest sibling, Peggy, unwittingly practicing for her eventual career in education, taught him to read before he ever set foot in a classroom. Once children’s stories were covered, he moved on to the family encyclopedia, an educational staple of many mid-20th century American homes. Further along than most by the time first grade began, he and another student were permitted in their reading class to occupy a corner of the classroom and lose themselves in any available story that seized their interest. He acquired a library card at the earliest opportunity and pored over every book on the shelves detailing the history of World War II and the Civil War. The daring adventures penned by Alistair MacLean were his favorite. When these were exhausted or unavailable, Readers Digest bound and abridged novels that amply lined his mother’s shelves would do. To this day, my father’s preferred posture is seated comfortably in a recliner with an open book. Conscious of it or not, he was building habits and forming values that would extend to his own children years later. My own career choice of librarianship undoubtedly began its formation during those early reading lessons decades ago between my aunt and father. For those of us led to believe we are the masters of our own fate, I would argue that nurture and influence stretch much further back into our familial past than we might imagine.

At 15, a friend loaned him “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy. “It’s a dangerous business,” Tolkien writes, “going out your door. You step onto the road, and if you don’t keep your feet, there’s no knowing where you might be swept off to.” Joel would spend hours discussing the volumes with his friend, enthralled not only at the exploits of the nine but, more importantly, moved by the spiritual themes undergirding the patient, expansive story, which, like many others he read, depicted places, real or imagined, dissimilar to the one he inhabited, fueling a desire to tread his own path into the unexplored world once given the opportunity. Something greater and deeper than the adventures he had read about continued to stir within, inspiring him soon to begin taking his first steps into a vocational life of faith.

Whether it was the stress of this call that weighed upon him or simple adolescent immaturity, Joel found himself during his senior year succumbing for a season, due to the influence of friends, to more than a passing interest in alcohol, a developing habit that he managed to conceal from his abstinent parents. Late in the academic year, he would pass evenings several times a week with friends overindulging. He didn’t relish the taste, but it did the job and did it well. Certain evenings passed out of memory entirely; the manner in which he made it home on these occasions were left a mystery.

There are few times in life that bear stronger potential to form both our best and worst habits than adolescence, and at his rate, alcoholism could thereafter have grasped and held him captive with relative ease if left unchecked. Had it succeeded, the story told here would read differently or, perhaps, not be read at all. To our great fortune, however, resourcefulness is one of God’s most enduring though often overlooked qualities. Every tool is at his disposal to shape our circumstances and character as he sees fit. He would recognize in due time what awaited him without an adjustment and would, thankfully, quit cold turkey. He would never touch another drop. The lessons learned would be put to good use, as they should for any seasoned minister. There is no shame in possessing a past, especially if it offers a personal education on the meaning of grace. And who better to comprehend and appreciate the lessons of one’s past in humility than those committed to professional ministry in the service of others, each with their own pasts? Christ saves us all from something.

Joel had spent abundant time pondering these and other spiritual matters for much of his brief life thus far, which led him eventually to consider whether it hinted at a call to a career focused wholly on God’s work. But to what, exactly? The works of Scripture, especially in the Old Testament, do not always describe the “call” of God in precisely the way many of us understand it today. Then, the Levites fulfilled the “professional” function, but primarily due to bloodline; it was a “default calling,” if you will. Many of those “called” who we read about were tasked with a very specific job in mind that did not necessarily carry a socially- or culturally-defined title that limited their role and responsibilities: be fruitful, build an ark, father a nation, lead my people, conquer, save my people, be anointed as king, rebuild the city, etc. All were called of God, but to an ordained task, not a defined title. I have met those who pursued a call in seminary who did not belong there, and I have known instructors who shared that observation. While there is no clear fault in following a call in the best way we know with the information we have, it’s wise to consider that we may limit God to think he can work with us only within the confines of professional ministry, though it most certainly has its place.

As best as Joel could surmise, just as many others do, his call should be pursued as a leader and shepherd of a congregation much like the one of which he’d long been a part, so he duly set out to obey prayerfully in the best way he saw fit. Consulting with his church’s pastor as well as select deacons in the body, he was approved and officially licensed into ministry. The duration of his first sermon barely gave listeners time enough to warm their seats after only seven minutes in the pulpit, but the brevity was no discouragement to him. Joel would continue in that direction.

At long last, graduation arrived. He summarily struck out on the road leading from town, blazing past furrowed fields over which he’d once driven. From here, there would be no stolen glances toward the tractors carving the dirt hours on end, though perhaps the metaphorical but fitting words of Christ, to whom he had pledged himself, echoed in his mind as he fixed his gaze forward and forged ahead.

“No one who puts his hand to the plow and looks back is fit for the kingdom of God.”

Just as the plow prepares the ground for the growth it will foster, Joel was unknowingly headed not yet into a life of career ministry but rather one of patient preparation for a task God had designed for him years later, a task which he would share with another. Her story began many miles southeast of the quiet farmlands spread across the Panhandle, nearer the noisy, steam-pluming refineries stretching along the lengthy coasts of the Gulf. Hers was a different hope for the future they would soon inhabit together.

Dropout

“. . . the great evil of the church has always been the presence in it of persons unsuited for the work required of them there. One very simple sifting rule would be, that no one should be admitted to the clergy who had not first proved himself capable of making a life in some other calling.”

– George MacDonald, “The Curate’s Awakening”

I reluctantly cracked open the heavy tome a fourth time, attempting to plow once more through the Old Testament survey reading assignment. I had already completed four years majoring as an undergraduate in the study of Scripture, not to mention in the original languages, so much of the information in the textbook had been covered. The scholasticism curved slightly steeper here at the graduate level, however. Seminarians all enroll in the same preliminary courses, college credit notwithstanding, so there was no getting around it. Having previously been guided through similar information, I should have found it simple enough. While this ought to have been the case, I struggled to maintain focus not a week into my third semester, second year, in a course of study that would ultimately earn myself the degree “Master of Divinity.”

After attempt number four failed, exasperated, I surrendered and placed the book aside. I uttered a brief, sincere, desperate prayer, expressing my lost interest in my chosen field, wondering if it meant I was lost as well. I had a decision to make. On the one hand, the scale seemed to tip decidedly in favor of remaining where I was. I understood the value of staying the course, of maintaining a commitment. I had graduated from my alma mater with highest honors and had received the religion department’s top award for an exiting senior. I tutored Greek and was even given an opportunity or two as a senior to fill in for professors in a couple of classes. I hadn’t left myself with a wealth of options post-college, having both majored and minored in “Christian Studies.” Due to my performance as an undergrad, my tuition here was covered (word to the wise: finishing formal education debt-free is not to be taken lightly). My parents were ministers whose experiences had deeply influenced my siblings and me enough to consider pursuing the profession. Then there was the pesky, unwanted impression of turning your back on your perceived calling; surely one doesn’t “drop out” of seminary without incurring the wrath of God, or at least his ire. All signs advised staying put.

On the other hand, there was scant as much other than feelings. Nevertheless, I thought, what if my difficulties and lingering reservations were evidence that maybe, just maybe, I wasn’t called to this at all, that I was simply a good student and nothing more, mistaken about the career that best lies before me? After all, here I was, attending classes in a different seminary than that at which I began and in less than a year’s time, having believed the unease I had felt beneath the surface at the outset simply necessitated a change of scenery, carrying me to this moment and this place. Here I was back in my familiar home state, and still I had little or no passion remaining to serve as either a minister or academic. I wasn’t spiritually disillusioned but professionally uninspired and uncertain. If my heart was no longer in it, perhaps the rest of me should no longer remain either.

Not willing or ready to abandon recklessly a relatively secure station in life for God-knows-what, I sought the counsel of a trusted friend as well as my parents, who themselves were serving in ministry. I expressed my thoughts that perhaps I wasn’t where I belonged, though I hadn’t determined precisely what else there could be. I have heard since that one should not quit a job until you have another waiting for you; thoughtful words, indeed, but a few more years would pass before I gleaned such wisdom. To my surprise, they each recommended withdrawal, and I found myself thankful for friends and especially parents who so often supported and trusted my decisions. I would sleep on it and find resolve in the morning.

My course determined, I set out the next day to begin the process and paperwork, but there was one task that first needed attention. I had the privilege not more than a week or two prior of having begun a position as a graduate assistant for one of the seminary’s esteemed professors. I now had to deliver the inconvenient news that he would have to search for another assistant so unexpectedly soon into the semester. I couldn’t be certain how he would receive it. Both the dean and assistant dean of the previous seminary, where I also served as a grad assistant, went to great pains to persuade me to stay after I had decided to return to Texas, and it was difficult not to feel their efforts were wholly self-interested. It was, after all, a fledgling seminary on the cusp of accreditation, so retaining rather than losing students was a priority for them.

I arrived at his convenience and seated myself in his office, coming straight to the point. I no longer believed seminary is where I belonged; I would be withdrawing. His response was equally direct and honest, and what he said has stayed with me to this day. After expressing genuine respect for and understanding of my decision, he replied, “I’d ask that you not share this outside of these walls, but there are other students here who ought to make that decision.”

_______________

As the year 2000 dawned, the magazine “Christianity Today” selected C. S. Lewis’s “Mere Christianity” as the best religious book of the 20th century. If you take the time to read this and Lewis’s other works — not only the more popular but nonetheless timeless and outstanding Narnia series — you begin to understand the unique gift he possessed to illustrate, explain, and simplify even the most complex of theological concepts. I know some who would argue this point, but I discovered his work at a spiritually unsettled time in my life and found him to be a clear breath of fresh air in the thin, stifling atmosphere of skepticism. In his deft and capable hands, he demonstrated that it can, in fact, make logical sense to be a believer. While no man is infallible, I have found my faith encouraged and bolstered time and again when I revisit his works.

As original and unique as his thoughts were, even the best among us have been mentored or taught, formally or informally. “No man is an island,” as John Donne famously put it. Lewis’s “master,” as he would dub him, was George MacDonald, a man he never met but whose writing deeply influenced him and many others whose names have overshadowed his own.

I came across MacDonald shortly before my decision to withdraw, thanks to a very well-read friend who never lacked for literature both to recommend and lend. Published in 1864, “The Curate’s Awakening” tells the story of Thomas Wingfold, a minister who finds himself in a crisis of belief after his Christian faith is intellectually challenged. While there is a wealth of insight in the story for anyone who might find themselves even a century-and-a-half later in a similar crisis, among my favorite quotes is the gem above, spoken by Wingfold’s mentor, of sorts, who patiently guides him back to his faith.

MacDonald must have encountered in his own life the “great evil” of men unsuited for the ministry. I’ve wished he could have further unpacked this claim, even if spoken through a fictitious yet truth-telling protagonist in a novel. Perhaps I should read more of his works and search it out. I know, nevertheless, that these words struck a chord with me at a critical time. They and my professor’s private opinion shared also confirmed observations I had made over the course of a year in seminary, if not earlier, by those “called” to a life of professional church ministry.

While the Protestants among us applaud what Luther and the Reformers accomplished with the doctrine of the priesthood of the believer, I’ve wondered what good or ill this truth, by extension, has done for the conviction of those who believe they have been “called” to ministry. In the same way I do not need a priest to mediate God’s truth, likewise my calling is between myself and God, as it goes; who’s to dispute it?

_______________

The evening came on, and I joined my acquaintance and his friend for a little company. The former had recently finished seminary; the latter was nearing the end. I was somewhere between the second and third semester, already wondering in the back of my mind if I shouldn’t be elsewhere in life. The conversations I would hear rather than join that evening would only sow further uncertainty, along with a measure of disappointment.

I can’t recall finer details, but they conversed easily and freely. It was loud, bawdy, and more to the point, when women were mentioned, unapologetically and wholly objectifying. There was alcohol, which wasn’t necessarily a problem, but thrown atop everything else I was hearing from a pair ostensibly “called,” it certainly didn’t elevate my impression, which I kept to myself.

Granted, we all feel the need to blow off steam, and we all benefit from friends, or should, who allow us to speak our minds candidly. However, the best friends hold us accountable, and I confess I had expected better from future shepherds, so to speak. My acquaintance would later tell me in a private moment that, all evidence considered, he had arrived at the conclusion there likely wasn’t a God; he would ultimately change professions. His friend, to the best of my knowledge, moved on into ministry. Learning what I did that evening, wherever he landed is no place I wanted to be.

I could tell as well of ministerial undergrads who stole books from the university library where I held a work study job for 2 1/2 years, or the classmate and coworker who continued to pursue theological studies post-college, only to determine, like my acquaintance, that he was an atheist, albeit an atheist with a purpose. He would find his 15-minutes of fame years later after filing suit against the military for their refusal to allow him to serve as a humanist chaplain. Video I discovered online of a lecture he had delivered to an audience unfamiliar with his past revealed a curious affectation he had also developed — a crisp but unmistakably clean British accent. I gathered from such that he had either suffered a bump to his brain’s left hemisphere, or his theological education, not to mention his careful and conscientious presentation of himself, was deliberately tailored to gain the admiration of others rather than to edify the body of Christ.

In very recent years, I’ve known and heard of career ministers abandoning the profession and their congregations long before retirement over reasons not entirely clear to me or others, and some of them have done so in dramatic and disappointing fashion, leaving a trail of damaged relationships and churches in their wake. We’ve all heard of prominent pastors who have made the headlines taking it a step further and abandoning their faith as well. Then there are those who happily stay in place and whose behavior or doctrine falls far short of the mark. I heard of one recently whose teaching strayed so far from a fundamental doctrine laid plain in Scripture, it was worth questioning whether or not he takes the time to read it at all. And I haven’t even begun to mention claims of sexual misconduct, in some cases criminal, which the press is always pleased to share with the public. Regardless of whether it’s burnout, moral failing, or something else, it leaves me discouraged, and I return to MacDonald’s words, wishing, perhaps, that they had chanced to read them years before, if not to dissuade them from their calling to elevate its significance, prompting them to have made a wiser choice.

_______________

Future ministers, at least in Baptist institutions, are encouraged to take a good, hard, introspective look at their call early into their formal education. There is no grade to be earned in doing so, nor is there an august body of professors or clergymen before whom you stand to be judged on whether or not your call is valid. This call, your call, is between you and the Creator. That being said, I do believe there are enough who mistake a call simply to be an authentic, faithful follower of Christ in life, generally speaking, as a call to professional ministry. Feeling poignantly touched by the Gospel and its truth in a life-altering way is, in my opinion, something all believers ought to experience. And such believers are meant to infiltrate every profession, not just the clergy. The command — the “call,” if you will — to “go out into all the world,” can’t happen if we don’t actually go out into all the world.

In his first recorded letter to Timothy, Paul laid it out for those desirous of the task of “overseer”:

Whoever aspires to be an overseer desires a noble task. Now the overseer is to be above reproach, faithful to his wife, temperate, self-controlled, respectable, hospitable, able to teach, not given to drunkenness, not violent but gentle, not quarrelsome, not a lover of money. He must manage his own family well and see that his children obey him, and he must do so in a manner worthy of full respect (If anyone does not know how to manage his own family, how can he take care of God’s church?). He must not be a recent convert, or he may become conceited and fall under the same judgment as the devil. He must also have a good reputation with outsiders, so he will not fall into disgrace and into the devil’s trap.

I can’t help but notice that Paul opens with “whoever aspires to be” rather than “whoever is called to.” It appears one can actually choose this noble task. However, there are a few expectations. Do you have the inherent qualities required for the job? You’re welcome to earn the degree, but the best of what’s expected can’t necessarily be learned in a classroom. For many, you either have it or you don’t, perhaps in much the same way my oldest child has natural, God-given athletic abilities that I never had and never will.

I consider myself privileged to know at least a couple of men who fit the bill, degreed or not. My father and father-in-law both spent the greater part of their professional lives in career ministry in one form or another, and I have seen in them the qualities Paul details in the passage above. The degree, if we’re honest, could assist with only one — able to teach — insofar as the coursework would provide content for instruction. The ability to teach, however, along with the rest, comes from somewhere else. Moreover, with this ability should accompany an understanding on whose authority one is teaching.

“Thus saith the Lord.” There are few bolder pronouncements in Scripture than this, delivered most often by the prophets. It is not a phrase one would utter unless absolutely certain what followed was indeed the holy thoughts of God himself. Yet the minister, as interpreter and teacher, effectually serves as God’s mouthpiece each moment he steps into a pulpit and opens the book, whether he has considered the weight of this responsibility or not. There is no greater position of power and influence, in my opinion, and it is for this function alone I find MacDonald’s words above cautioning entrance into the profession most relevant. It reminds me of what our beloved professor of the original New Testament language shared with us at the close of our third course: “Students, you now know just enough Greek to be dangerous.”

I hope I do not sound contentiously dismissive of anyone’s call to ministry. Scripture is replete with examples of those who appeared unqualified for the task given to them. God uses the “weak things of the world to shame the strong,” as we know and read. It is one of his most beautiful and attractive characteristics that he utilizes those the callous world blithely casts aside. But I also believe God can and does equip us for the jobs he gives us, and it is worth at least a moment of the time granted to us to consider whether or not he has, in fact, gifted us accordingly. The lives of those we shepherd, by choice, by call, or both, may depend on it.

_______________

For almost 18 years, I have spent my professional life in public libraries. It is a career that has treated me very well, and I hope I have shown the same courtesy to those I’ve served. I’ve enjoyed successes that many never achieve and was convinced by 40 that if my career ended at that age, I would be satisfied with what had been accomplished. I have wondered on a handful of occasions what might have happened had I stayed put in seminary, but there’s no way to know. I have never regretted the decision, and I’ve never felt, judging from the way life has worked out, that God is displeased somehow with the decision. I have much to be thankful for, and I believe he had something to do with where I’ve ended up. I have considered that ministry may be somewhere down the road. It seems a waste of an education such as I absorbed to never utilize it in a professional context. In any event, it’s up to someone other than me, and I hope I’m attentive to the call if or when it arrives.

Maybe it’s presumptuous of me, but I’ve imagined returning to my alma mater to impart a few words of wisdom to the undergraduate ministers in training. Given the opportunity, I would likely open with MacDonald’s words. While my interest would not lie in dissuading them from their “noble task,” I would hope they might gain a greater respect for their call and consider its weight. It’s easy enough to take a class and earn the credit. It’s much harder to lead others desperate and thirsty for spiritual truth, especially if we’re meant to lead elsewhere.